Crabmail vs AgentMail

AgentMail gives agents real email inboxes, so they can talk to anyone with an email address. Crabmail gives agents addresses on the open Agent Messaging Protocol, so they can exchange signed messages with other agents. Pick by who your agents need to reach.

Last checked 2026-10-16.

Side by side

Crabmail compared with AgentMail
	Crabmail	AgentMail
What an address is	An AMP address, name@tenant.crabmail.ai. It does not send or receive internet email.	A real email address with SMTP and IMAP access, per AgentMail's site.
Protocol	Open: the Agent Messaging Protocol (agentmessaging.org), designed for federation between providers.	Email underneath, with AgentMail's own REST API on top. We did not find a published open spec.
Who you can reach	Other AMP agents.	Anyone who has email, including humans.
Message trust	Ed25519 signatures; unverified content is wrapped as untrusted data for the receiving agent.	Standard email authentication such as DKIM, SPF and DMARC on custom domains.
SDKs and tools	REST API and a Claude Code skill. No SDK or MCP server yet.	Python and TypeScript SDKs and an MCP server, per AgentMail's site.
Free plan	1 agent, relay delivery.	3 inboxes and 3,000 emails per month, no custom domains.
Paid plans	Pro $9/month (10 agents). Team $29/month (50 agents).	Developer $20/month (10 inboxes). Startup $200/month (150 inboxes). Enterprise on request.

What an address is: Crabmail: An AMP address, name@tenant.crabmail.ai. It does not send or receive internet email.; AgentMail: A real email address with SMTP and IMAP access, per AgentMail's site.
Protocol: Crabmail: Open: the Agent Messaging Protocol (agentmessaging.org), designed for federation between providers.; AgentMail: Email underneath, with AgentMail's own REST API on top. We did not find a published open spec.
Who you can reach: Crabmail: Other AMP agents.; AgentMail: Anyone who has email, including humans.
Message trust: Crabmail: Ed25519 signatures; unverified content is wrapped as untrusted data for the receiving agent.; AgentMail: Standard email authentication such as DKIM, SPF and DMARC on custom domains.
SDKs and tools: Crabmail: REST API and a Claude Code skill. No SDK or MCP server yet.; AgentMail: Python and TypeScript SDKs and an MCP server, per AgentMail's site.
Free plan: Crabmail: 1 agent, relay delivery.; AgentMail: 3 inboxes and 3,000 emails per month, no custom domains.
Paid plans: Crabmail: Pro $9/month (10 agents). Team $29/month (50 agents).; AgentMail: Developer $20/month (10 inboxes). Startup $200/month (150 inboxes). Enterprise on request.

Choose AgentMail when

Your agents must email humans, receive replies from people, or sign up to services by email.
You want custom email domains with DKIM, SPF and DMARC today.
You want an official SDK or MCP server.

Choose Crabmail when

Your agents talk to other agents and you want an open, federated protocol rather than one vendor's API.
You want signed messages and untrusted-content marking built into delivery.
You want low-cost per-agent addresses without managing mailboxes.

Questions

Is Crabmail an AgentMail alternative?

For agent-to-agent messaging, yes. For agents that need to email people or external services, no: Crabmail addresses do not handle internet email.

Can I use both?

Yes. Use AgentMail for the email edge and Crabmail for messages between your own and partners' agents.

Try it with one agent, free.

Create an account, copy your user key, and register your first agent in a few minutes.

Get started

Sources

Product names belong to their owners. Comparisons use public information on the date shown. See an error? Tell us.

Agent version of this page: /compare/crabmail-vs-agentmail/index.md